Board of Peace Under Fire for Pressuring Palestinians as Humanitarian Crisis Deepens

SAFA — The Gaza Board of Peace is facing mounting criticism from Palestinian political analysts who accuse it of prioritizing Israeli security demands over urgent humanitarian needs, as continued Israeli attacks, restrictions on aid, and delays in reconstruction leave hundreds of thousands of displaced Palestinians exposed to worsening conditions.

The criticism comes amid a widening gap between international promises to end the war and rebuild Gaza and the reality facing Palestinians who remain displaced, deprived of adequate shelter, and struggling to obtain food, medicine, and other essential supplies.

Political analysts Dr. Iyad al-Qarra and Wissam Afifa argue that the board's approach places disproportionate pressure on Palestinian factions to surrender their weapons and transfer administrative authority, while failing to apply comparable pressure on Israel to fulfill its ceasefire commitments.

Their criticism raises broader questions about whether the board can advance a credible recovery process while humanitarian assistance and reconstruction remain entangled with political and security conditions.

Al-Qarra: Israeli Demands Take Priority Over Ceasefire Obligations

Palestinian political analyst Dr. Iyad al-Qarra questioned the effectiveness of the Board of Peace, saying it had failed to translate its declared responsibilities into meaningful action.

Speaking in a press interview, al-Qarra said the board had made little progress in stopping Israeli attacks, ensuring the delivery of humanitarian aid, or advancing the administrative and political arrangements intended for Gaza.

He argued that continued Israeli attacks and Palestinian deaths, including those of women and children, demanded a more decisive international response.

Instead, according to al-Qarra, the board has accommodated Israeli conditions by linking humanitarian and political issues to the disarmament of Palestinian factions without first securing compliance with fundamental ceasefire obligations.

Those obligations include ending attacks, implementing withdrawal arrangements, and allowing humanitarian assistance into Gaza.

Al-Qarra described a double standard in the board's treatment of the parties.

He said the board relies on appeals and encouragement when addressing the Israeli government but makes direct demands of Palestinian factions regarding weapons and the transfer of authority.

In his assessment, this approach places Palestinians under immediate political pressure while allowing Israel to avoid an equivalent level of scrutiny and accountability.

Al-Qarra also accused the board of presenting misleading information about the volume of humanitarian aid entering Gaza, saying its statements align with Israeli accounts despite international humanitarian reports documenting severe shortages and deteriorating living conditions.

His criticism extended to the administrative arrangements for Gaza.

He said the board had failed to seriously follow up on the work of the proposed administrative committee or complete the arrangements necessary for its members to enter Gaza and begin their duties.

For al-Qarra, these delays raise questions about the seriousness of efforts to enable Palestinian institutions to manage the territory's civilian affairs.

Afifa: Gaza's Winter Disaster Is Not Simply a Natural Catastrophe

Palestinian political analyst Wissam Afifa focused on the humanitarian emergency unfolding in Gaza's displacement camps, where heavy rainfall and flooding have devastated already fragile shelters.

Afifa criticized the Board of Peace for treating the destruction caused by winter storms primarily as a weather-related emergency while, in his view, overlooking the political and military circumstances that left Palestinians so vulnerable.

He argued that the widespread destruction of homes and infrastructure during Israel's war, combined with restrictions on the entry of shelter materials, had turned seasonal rainfall into a life-threatening humanitarian crisis.

According to figures cited by Afifa, approximately 70,000 tents were flooded within 12 hours, while Gaza's Civil Defense received 1,500 emergency calls.

He also reported that five Palestinians died after a sandbank collapsed in Deir al-Balah.

Afifa said these incidents could not be separated from the mass displacement of Palestinians and the lack of safe housing, adequate drainage, and basic protective supplies.

In his analysis, the flooding exposed the consequences of prolonged destruction and restrictions on humanitarian access rather than an emergency caused by rainfall alone.

Linking Humanitarian Relief to Disarmament

Afifa warned that one of the most troubling aspects of the board's approach was its continued linkage of humanitarian relief to the issue of Palestinian factions' weapons.

He argued that urgent civilian needs should not be subordinated to security negotiations, particularly when displaced families remain without adequate shelter and essential services.

Afifa also criticized the board's failure to address delays in Gaza's recovery over the past year, despite acknowledging that Israel had not fully implemented its commitments.

He said this approach shifts attention away from Israeli restrictions and the obstacles preventing essential supplies from reaching the population.

Afifa further argued that the board had adopted elements of Israel's security narrative, particularly in attributing responsibility for the stalled political process to Hamas.

He pointed to Hamas's reported acceptance of a roadmap presented by Nikolay Mladenov and to statements by mediators concerning Israeli ceasefire violations.

For Afifa, these developments highlight the need to assess the conduct and commitments of all parties rather than concentrating political demands on Palestinians alone.

UNRWA's Role and Gaza's Administrative Future Remain Unresolved

The criticism also extends to the institutional arrangements proposed for Gaza's humanitarian response and future administration.

Questions have been raised over the reported exclusion of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA), which has extensive experience delivering education, healthcare, and humanitarian services to Palestinian refugees.

Critics argue that sidelining an agency with an established operational network could further complicate relief efforts at a time when displacement, poverty, and humanitarian needs remain widespread.

The continued delay in enabling the proposed administrative committee to enter Gaza and begin its work has also fueled concerns about the viability of the announced transition arrangements.

Palestinian analysts question how meaningful administrative recovery can proceed while local institutions remain unable to exercise their responsibilities and essential decisions continue to depend on Israeli restrictions and approvals.

These unresolved issues have added to doubts about whether the proposed governance framework can adequately address Palestinian needs and priorities.

Calls for Accountability and Unrestricted Humanitarian Access

The debate over the Board of Peace reflects wider Palestinian concerns about the relationship between security arrangements, humanitarian relief, and the future governance of Gaza.

Al-Qarra and Afifa's criticism centers on the argument that urgent civilian protections should not be delayed while negotiations over disarmament and political administration continue.

Their assessments also highlight demands for stronger international action to address Israeli ceasefire violations and restrictions on humanitarian access.

Among the measures identified as necessary are ending attacks on civilians, opening crossings, allowing the entry of winter shelter materials and medical supplies, enabling humanitarian organizations to operate, and facilitating the work of Palestinian administrative institutions.

Reconstruction is another central concern, particularly the need to restore housing and essential infrastructure while protecting Palestinians' rights to their land, property, and return to their communities.

As displaced families continue to face flooding, inadequate shelter, and severe shortages, the criticism raises a fundamental question about the international framework for Gaza: whether it can deliver meaningful civilian protection and recovery while the political and security disputes surrounding the ceasefire remain unresolved.

For the Palestinian analysts, the immediate test is whether commitments to peace can be translated into tangible improvements in the lives of Gaza's population.

Source : Safa News